
Andrew, in blue!
Dressing very small, new humans is fraught with challenges these days. Did you know that there are people who actually judge you, based on your baby’s clothing? Your open-mindedness is being measured. For instance, dressing your baby girl in all pink in this day and age apparently signifies to some people that either you are ignorant, or you are an insensitive clod who buys into the social construct that says we dress our babies according to their genital presentation.
But what if there are other things to consider? What if, for instance, you really, really like pink? Do you not dress your girls in pink just because you’re worried about what everyone else thinks?
Of course, this issue goes beyond pink and blue. This problem exists on many levels. I’ve ranted before about Disney princesses and gendered play. But I’ve never had so many people talk to me directly about the issue of clothing until I started carrying around a long-haired baby boy with long black eyelashes whom I sometimes dress in purple. When I correct their gender assumptions about my child, most of these people apologize profusely. But I’ve had other responses that really trouble me. One woman told me I should cut his hair and dress him in primary colors only. Another was just shocked and speechless. I’ve actually decided to stop correcting people’s assumptions about his gender because I’m rather chagrined at the responses.
What the hell, people? Why is this so damned important?
I have two older girls. And when they were babies, I was gifted YEARS’ worth of nice, quality baby clothing in which to dress them. And I would have to say that about 90% of those clothes were pink or purple. But I didn’t dress them in pink or purple to make sure everyone knew I had girls. That’s just…what I had. I quit my job to care for my children. We didn’t have a whole lot of money. And we didn’t need to buy or acquire other clothing. I don’t really care for pink, personally, but my girls looked adorable. And when I had to add to their clothing, I chose colors I prefer, like green and blue. I didn’t really care that others would then identify my baby as a boy. And they did. All the time. Was it a simpler time, just 6 years ago?
Now I have a little boy. And, again, I dress him in whatever I’ve been given. My friend passed down all her boys’ clothing to me, so I have lots of stuff with which to dress my son. I would say that 90% of the clothing I have is blue. I’m happy to dress him in this clothing because he looks beautiful, and because blue is my very favorite color.

I prefer my pigs to be pink.
I have had more than one person give me the hairy eyeball for dressing my boy in blue clothing. Because I guess I’m not being subversive enough. I’m not forwarding the cause. I’m acting in a stereotypical fashion. And I suppose that to them, I am part of the problem.
But I have a little something to say about this, and it’s been hard to write. I don’t want to offend anyone. I have friends who are gender queer; I have friends who fight every day to live in the gender identity that they choose, rather than the one that was assigned to them via biology. And I support them 100%. But I have to say this anyway.
I don’t care how you dress your baby. It just doesn’t matter to me.
I agree with the idea of using more neutral, unisex colors and styles for dressing babies, if for no other reason than to send the message that gender identification doesn’t matter, especially when it comes to babies. But in practice…it’s just not that important to me how you dress your baby.
There are other elements to consider, or at least there are for me. I’m very invested in being more environmentally conscientious, and more financially practical in my consumption of goods. I’ve made a commitment to live more simply, to make a smaller footprint, to use what I have and what I can find. I’m trying to only buy “new” if I’ve exhausted every other alternative. I want to reuse. So I try to find my family’s clothing from hand-me-downs, clothing swaps, thrift stores, yard sales, and … well, you get the idea. And cool, boutique gender-neutral clothes haven’t really made it to the second-hand market yet. Or at least not where I’m looking.
But, anyway, it’s not on my agenda.
It comes down to this: we are a nation obsessed with the superficial. So although I agree with the idea of dressing babies in gender-neutral styles or using unisex themes because, really, we shouldn’t need to impose ideas as to what is “gender appropriate” in baby clothing, I also don’t want to get caught up on that level of judging people according to the way they present themselves. It’s a double-edged sword. I can’t win, either way.
Babies. Unless you give people some hints, chances are no one will be able to tell if you have a small human of the girl variety or of the boy variety. This, of course, doesn’t stop every stranger who sees you from inquiring as to the gender of your baby.
Why? I think, basically, because people are curious. And, for some reason, learning a baby’s gender is something people want to know. Sometimes, it’s a conversation prompt. “Oh, he’s a boy? I had a little boy, and he liked to climb my bookcases. Does your little boy like to climb?”
And sometimes, I think they ask because they can’t tell, and that makes some people uncomfortable.
In the bigger picture, how you dress your baby doesn’t matter. Babies are babies. And the way you dress your baby will not immediately affect your baby. So let’s stop worrying so much about how everyone else is dressing their babies. Dress your baby the way that is most practical to you. You only have a small window anyway, because one day maybe your 3-year-old daughter will declare an end to pants FOREVER. Or decide that she wants to wear only black. These are the times when clothing becomes important. When you allow your children to express themselves through their clothing choices.

I'm way too cool for the sidelines...
Our middle child, Laurel (6), may be the girliest girl I’ve ever met. She wants to look her best, and her idea of what is “best” differs from mine by about 179 degrees. I try to make sure she wears seasonally appropriate clothing, but that’s about all the say I get in what she wears. Monday, she was sitting across from me at the table, having a discussion with her older sister about friendship. Kelsey (8) was pining for her friend Ilana, and she told Laurel that she and Ilana were “sisters” because they love each other so much. And my 6-year-old, dressed head-to-toe in Disney princess pink fluffiness, says in her most matter-of-fact voice, “Well, when you grow up, if you want to, you two can marry, because that’s totally legal!” And my heart did a little leap of joy.
I love my Dad even when he dresses me funny.
Because ultimately, it’s not the way you dress your baby that will make a difference, that will make a brighter future for him or her, or for us all as a society. It’s what you teach her about equality, about women’s rights. It’s how you stand behind him when he wants to wear skirts to elementary school because he loves skirts. It’s about having amazing conversations that show them the world as it is, and the world they can transform it into, through their actions and their understanding, and the way they choose to live their lives.
So, hey, dress your baby the way you want, according to what’s important to you. But don’t judge me for doing likewise. I’d rather tackle more important ways I can address gender and equality issues than worry if my baby looks too butch for our toddler playdate.